“Ramona (1936), based on the novel by Helen Hunt Jackson, is the story of a half-caste girl (Loretta Young) who falls in love with an Indian youth (Don Ameche) whose sincerity and fidelity make him respected by all. Rejected by the aunt who raised her, Ramona and her lover run off, are wed, and seek out a pastoral life in the arcadia that surrounds them. In this picture Catholicism is a saving grace; the tone is sentimental, but never sappy. The plot may sound operatic, but is really quite humble in its aspirations. It is, after all, a Romance, not a romantic comedy or an operetta, or a kitschy dalliance. Romance as a genre was much more defined and developed in that era, and the original book was a perennial favorite, having been filmed previously by D.W. Griffith and others.
The storyline is not new, of course, but some of its attitudes are refreshingly contemporary, if not revisionist. The white characters in the drama are depicted as prejudiced, greedy, opportunistic and suspicious, while persons of color are shown to be honest, hard-working and virtuous, and with considerable dimension. There is nothing pat about any of the main players because their motivations are quickly and economically made clear. The Indians are driven off their prosperous land by whites who have taken advantage of legal loopholes. The matter is not skirted but dealt with straight-on, because the drama demands it. Consequently, amongst the love story are to be found humanitarian notions.
William Skall, who would later contribute to such vast color mural-storytelling as Quo Vadis and The Silver Chalice, was behind the camera, and he well qualifies himself as one of the great ‘painters of light’ in the cinema. The cameras were huge and bulky, the lighting required was fierce and hot, and the demands from Technicolor on the creative side often severe, but Skall captures the moods and subtleties of Old California in an almost Mission Style manifestation of pictorialness.”
-Peter Melmoth